Alexander Ivanovich Terenov's book Under Three Flags: The Saga of the submarine
cruiser Chakra/K-43 is a story of the submarine- K-43 in the Soviet Navy and the
Chakra in the Indian Navy, which spent a small part of her chequered career flying the
Indian flag, and brought the Indian Navy into the exciting era of nuclear propulsion. The
story of the Russian Charlie class SSGN, has been told from a very personal point of
view, and because of this it becomes an engaging human narrative which never loosens
its grip on the reader's attention, says VAdm (Retd) R Ganesh who has translated the
book from russian to english. Salute (www.salute.co.in) presents the excerpts of the book in its original form.
They were looking for a submarine
with tube-launched anti-ship and landattack
missiles, but at that time we did
not have weapons of this type. Evidently
after that visit to the K-43 by the Indian
delegation in August 1982 the final
choice of the submarine was made.
This was hardly surprising, as the appearance
of this class of submarine in
our Navy was an unpleasant surprise for
the carrier and battle-group formations
of NATO. Compact, and armed with the
unique underwater-launched cruise Amethyst
missile, this submarine certainly
complicated life for the adversary. Its
short time of flight, low trajectory and
lethal radius made counter-measures difficult.
The submarine needed no external
target indication and was capable of attacks
based on self-generated target data,
which overcame other disadvantages,
especially in restricted seas such as the
Mediterranean or in confined waterways
such as the Malacca or Gibraltar Straits.
Even today, having more modern missiles,
we experience difficulty in exploiting the
advantage of their longer range because
of the absence of target data. The Project
670 submarines were thus unique, especially
in those years.
Rajiv Gandhi the first Indian to receive the submarine in outer harbour, boards the
ship to announce the nuclear submarine era for the Indian Navy
On return to Kamchatka after completing
the passage of the submarine I
continued serving in the 10th Division,
and in 1983 they appointed me in command
of the K-43. (I learnt later that
Captain 2nd Rank LZ Lupach was to have
been nominated, but he was apparently
wiser – evidently he was better informed.)
People have often asked me why I was
particularly chosen for this assignment. I
always reply with the old anecdote about
the young lady of easy virtue, who when
persistently asked how it was that she,
a Philology graduate from the Moscow
State University with honours in three
foreign languages had become a highclass
call-girl, breezily replied: "I guess I
was just lucky"! Of course now I permit
myself to laugh it off, after the assigned
task has been successfully accomplished
and the crew as well the submarine have
inscribed a shining page in the history of
our country's submarine fleet. But at the
time I was in no mood to laugh, as the
relocation from Kamchatka to Primorye,
the prospect of a long period under refit
and an uncertain future all took their toll
on both my wife and me. The previous
Commanding Officer NY Maryashin had
already been appointed in the Operational
Training Department of the Navy
in Moscow and was packing his suitcases.
Nikolai Yakovlevich was an experienced
and a highly respected commander who
had already finished five years in command
of the K-43, and had navigated
the submarine under the Arctic ice when
she was transferred from the Northern to
the Pacific Fleet. It was as I went through
the process of taking over from him that
I began to understand, with horror, the
rashness of the enterprise that I had embarked
on. The fact was that the majority
of the crew hadn't been to sea for several
years. The most knowledgeable of them
stayed back in Kamchatka, and many of
them had been drafted from submarines
of other Projects under refit, apparently
thinking that they were being sent on a
vacation to the fabled land of India. The
majority of officers and Warrant officers
were marvellous people, honest and sincere.
But, as they say, in the Navy there's
no cadre such as "good fellow." We needed
to be not only a good crew, but also
instructors capable of training three professional
Indian submarine crews, and
perhaps, spend a few years in India.
Having assessed the situation and arrived
at my decisions, I succeeded in
getting an appointment with the C-in-C
Pacific and informed him of my apprehensions
and suggestions. Admiral VV
Sidorov heard me out attentively, accepted
all my proposals, and issued the necessary directives. Briefly, my
proposals were that the crew was
to be urgently augmented from
the resources of the 10th Division
and sent to the Training Centre
at Obininsk for an inter-patrol refresher
course, then to Kamchatka
for acceptance of the next submarine
in the line and completion of
their work-up training tasks. After
having passed all the work-up
inspections and having qualified
as an operational crew, I wanted
them to be sent once again to to
the Obininsk Training Centre for a
month to study the specific features of
this submarine after her major modifications.
And only then should they be assigned
for the acceptance of the submarine
from the Dockyard, confirm her operational
readiness and take on the training
of foreign crews. The time allotted for
all this was not more than eight months.
I can't say that my plan was met with understanding
by my officers and Warrant
officers, especially those who had to fly
back to Kamchatka. They were
faced with a prolonged separation
from their families, absence
from their homes, and a colossal
amount of work. But my sailors
were happy at the prospect of
the exciting trips to Moscow and
Kamchatka, and the opportunity
to be real submariners on an operational
boat instead of rotting
in a never-ending refit. Perhaps
today I would not have taken that
risky course, but then I had some
experience and a lot of keenness,
and most important of all, I was
young and strong. …
An amusing incident that happened
that day. After sending the crew back to
Ribachi, in Paratunka I met some hunters
from Kamchatka. In a mellow mood after some dry wine in their company, I
heard the moving story of how they had
shot a bear and only later discovered her
lair with two four-month old cubs inside.
They took the cubs with them, realizing
they would not survive without their
mother. They proposed to rope me into
their rescue plan for the cubs by presenting
one of them to me. I don't know which
had the greater effect on me – the urge
to support wildlife or the case of white
wine which we had by this time emptied,
but my instinct let me down, and I acquiesced
to their plan. People often ask me
about intuition and how it helps in life.
My answer is that the head is used for
thinking, and the seat of the pants is for
sitting on; You shouldn't get the roles of
these two ends mixed up - if you do, be
prepared to look silly.
Singh is King: Captain Terenov with wife Mrs Tanya in Indian attire
I was wakened in my bunk early the
next morning by my face being licked
tenderly and covered with smacking
kisses. In my half-asleep state I thought
I was at home in bed with my wife, and
my arm automatically reached out to embrace
her – and opened my eyes to see a
shaggy, brown, impudent, hungry but altogether
lovable bear cub, which was licking
my ear and whispering erotic things
in it. The painful memory of how I had
got into this predicament came flooding
back. I should mention that the cabin I
was in had been "rented" to me by my old
shipmate from the K-320, Boris Blednov,
now the CO of K-201 and away on
leave. In 1979 we had been together (he
as ExO, and I as Captain's Assistant) on
the K-320 during her under-ice transit
from the Northern Fleet to Kamchatka.
On a few occasions we had surfaced in a
polinya, and played football on the pack
ice, and scared off polar bears. He was an
experienced CO, strict and fond of neatness
and order in his cabin as much as on
board his submarine. I benefited greatly
from his advice on naval as well as everyday
matters. I looked around the room
and thought to myself that a bull in a
china shop would have caused less havoc
than this bear cub in the captain's cabin,
and I would never be able to pay back
Boris in this lifetime. Clearly Mishka was
hungry; his intelligent doggy eyes spoke
for him – but other than beer I had nothing
else, so he and I knocked back a can
each. We both felt better at once, and began
to understand one another. I recalled
how the previous evening I chose one of
the cubs and jumped into a pool (which
had no water in it) where they were
awaiting their fate. One of them tore off
to the far corner, emitting a smelly jet of
something behind him which I straightaway
recognized as "bear sickness". The
other showed no fear at all, but stood up
on his hind legs and watched my actions
attentively and with great suspicion.
Then he winked at me - and that tilted
the balance in his favour. I feinted with
the left as advised by the tactics manual,
and grabbed him by the scruff of the neck
with my right hand (which neutralised
his main advantage – excellent reflexes
and two-inch long claws.) and dumped
him in a sack. These exertions were followed
by another drink, and then one for
the road, and another for the prize of the
hunt. And somehow in the dead of night
Mishka got free and "re-arranged" the
cabin.
Soon the cub became the pet and
mascot of the crew, and by a unit order
he was given a ration allowance and was
re-named Mashka, as he turned out to be
a female! She weighed fifteen kilos, and
her favourite treat was condensed milk,
which she became a virtuoso at drinking
straight from the jar. She would curl
her tongue up in a tube and suck out the
milk, then with one swirl of her tongue
would leave the jar spotlessly clean.
When the time came for our departure to
Obininsk there was a huge gathering of
people to see us off at the airfield. The
Division Commander wished Mashka
success in taking control of the bear population
in the European part of the country
and in improving their bloodline, and
gave permission for the aeroplane to take
off. Amazingly, she withstood the journey
beautifully; she strolled across the tarmac,
entered the spacious wooden crate
that had been made for her, and neither
the nine-hour flight nor the nine time
zones we crossed had the slightest effect
on her good spirits.
Extract of Under Three Flags: The Saga
of the submarine cruiser Chakra /K-43
Of Sasha and Charlie class Chakra
Vice Adm (Retd) AK SINGH
(former Commander-in-Chief Eastern
Naval Command)
I first met the then "young and handsome"
32 year old Captain 3rd Rank
(Lieutenant Commander) Alexander
Ivanovich Terenov, over 25 years ago, in
1983, in Vladivostok, where we had arrived
for nuclear submarine training (1983 -1986)
to operate the Russian Charlie class
SSGN, K-43 (later to become INS Chakra
under a three year lease 1988-1991). Alexander,
liked to be called Sasha, and thats
how I have referred to him ever since. By
the time our 30 month training finished,
Sasha, had been promoted twice over, and
was Captain 1st Rank (equal to Captain of
the Indian Navy).
For some of the Indian crew, this was
not our first visit to the former USSR, so
we were quite aware that the average Soviet
Navy submariner was a simple, friendly,
hardworking, hard drinking professional,
with a remarkable sense of humour. What
makes this book particularly readable, apart
from the 80 photographs in its 300 pages,
is that its written by a former Soviet Navy
submarine Captain, who saw the breakdown
of the USSR, and the transition of
the once mighty Soviet Navy, into a much
smaller, Russian Navy, which is still a very
potent force. Also, many Soviet Navy personnel
came to India, but few wrote about
their experiences with the Indian Navy in
English. In the case of Sasha, his direct association
with us was over 51/2 years (21/2
years in Vladivostok and three years in
Vishakapatnam). I saw Sasha in action at
sea in a closed nuclear submarine environment
for weeks at a stretch, and must place
on record, that he was truly very professional.
I would hate to be target, if Sasha
was carrying out a missile or torpedo attack
against me!! In February 2001, as Eastern
Fleet Commander, I was particpating with
my Fleet, in India's first ever International
Fleet Review (IFR) at Mumbai, where ships
from many foreign navies also participated.
Their were two destroyers from the Russian
Pacific Fleet, who had come from
from Vladivostok, under the command of
Vice Admiral Alexander Vasilievich Konev
(Deputy Commander-in-Chief, Pacific
Fleet), who was a submariner. This Russian
Admiral was very keen to meet me, so, after
gettiing official permission, myself and
a number of Indian submariners met the
Russians at an official "beer and lunch" at
the Submarine Base Complex, where the
very emotional Russian Admiral presented
me, the Depth gauge of INS Chakra. In true
submarine fashion, we also exchanged our
submarine badges, I took this Chakra souvenier
to Vishakapatnam, and installed it
(with a suitable brass plaque, recording its
history) inside the Indian Navy Submarine
Kursura "Submarine Museum", located on
the beach. Many years later, after I had retired,
Sasha (also retired) presented me a
Russian language copy of his book, which
is now translated into English, by Vice Admiral
RN Ganesh (Retired). I vividly recall
the various incidents mentioned by Sasha,
since I was present, but being a thorough
gentleman, he has omitted some truly awe
inspiring anecdotes of "sauna, vodka and
raw spirit". This book, is indeed a "must
read" for all professional submariners and
military personnel. The accompanying excerpts,
give a glimpse, of a bygone era, of
a fantastic period of interaction between
the Indian and Soviet Navies. I wish you all
happy reading!!